The Accumulative Instinct, from the Snapshots from "Puck" series (N128) issued by Duke Sons & Co. to promote Honest Long Cut Tobacco 1888

Editor: So, this color print titled "The Accumulative Instinct" is from 1888, created by W. Duke, Sons & Co., part of their 'Snapshots from "Puck"' series. The figures and domestic setting make it feel both humorous and subtly unsettling. What jumps out at you when you look at it? Curator: You know, what captivates me is how this seemingly simple domestic scene bursts with a controlled kind of chaos. It's like peering into a vaudeville act frozen in time. That father figure, the eager Ockstein, with his exaggerated features practically reaching for the child, while the child… well, the child's face is a masterclass in pure, unadulterated apprehension. Do you think this expresses an innocent father, or perhaps something less flattering? Editor: Hmm, less flattering... I see what you mean. There is a level of caricature to each member of this family and it really does give off the feeling they are performing some act. But does the image make any particular statement in regards to tobacco usage? Curator: Exactly! These were originally tobacco cards slipped into cigarette packs. Can you imagine finding *this* nestled amongst your tobacco? What a peculiar incentive! Perhaps the statement they intended to make isn't entirely clear through a modern lense. It is so interesting that it evokes an accumulation of wealth (and anxiety?) within the family—the very same way one may acquire these cigarette cards or even tobacco. I'm also interested in the shadow in the upper-right. Any thoughts? Editor: That's a little frightening actually! That simple portrait adds an entirely new element. Seeing it as some strange symbol or foreshadow makes you wonder...Well, I learned far more about tobacco advertising than I expected, and perhaps saw my anxieties on becoming a new parent validated, so thanks! Curator: Ha! See, even tobacco cards can lead us down the rabbit hole of existential dread. My pleasure!