Studies for Second Angel at Right, "Israel and the Law," Boston Public Library 1895 - 1916

Curator: This is John Singer Sargent's study for the Second Angel at Right, a preparatory sketch for his mural "Israel and the Law." Editor: The charcoal rendering evokes a sense of muscular tension, the figure captured mid-action, in dynamic contrapposto. Curator: Knowing this was for the Boston Public Library, Sargent was likely considering themes of civic duty and divine law. The angel’s placement within that context adds layers of meaning about power and justice. Editor: Indeed, we can see the use of chiaroscuro—light and shadow—to amplify the dramatic effect. His masterful use of line creates a vivid sense of form. Curator: It's important to recognize how Sargent, despite his reputation as a portraitist of the elite, engaged with broader social and religious narratives in his mural work. Editor: Absolutely, it is remarkable to study Sargent's process of resolving form. Curator: It encourages us to reflect on how those narratives are visualized and perpetuated through art.