Edinburgh gezien vanaf Edinburgh Castle c. 1870 - 1890

James Valentine captured this photograph of Edinburgh from Edinburgh Castle in the mid-19th century. This was a time when Scotland was grappling with its identity within the British Empire and experiencing rapid industrialization. The image presents a sweeping view of the city, and showcases Edinburgh’s blend of historical grandeur and modern progress. Yet, it's important to consider what is not readily visible here. The romanticized cityscape obscures the harsh realities of urban poverty and social inequality that were prevalent during this era. The imposing architecture symbolizes British power and the economic engines of the Industrial Revolution, but it casts a shadow on the experiences of the working class and marginalized communities. The photograph invites contemplation on how the grand narratives of progress often overshadow the lived experiences of many. It's a reminder to consider whose stories are told, and whose are left out of the frame.