Fish Seller c. 17th century

Curator: Jacob Toorenvliet’s "Fish Seller" presents a close grouping of figures rendered in delicate washes. It strikes me as unusually intimate. Editor: Indeed. The composition draws our attention to the interaction between the figures, but what can we say about their social positions based on their garments and the tools of labor displayed? Curator: Notice how Toorenvliet balances the composition with a precise use of light and shadow. The artist deftly employs subtle gradations of color to create a sense of depth and volume. Editor: The woman’s direct gaze towards the viewer implicates us in the dynamics of the scene. Are we observing commerce or exploitation? Curator: Perhaps it is the harmonious arrangement of forms that ultimately matters, as this elevates the scene beyond mere representation. Editor: It is a powerful reminder that what we deem beautiful is entangled in issues of identity and power.