Untitled c. 1930s

Editor: This intriguing artwork, simply titled "Untitled," is attributed to Caroline Whiting Fellows and likely dates back to the 1930s. It appears to be a vibrant photograph or possibly a watercolor, depicting two red apples and what seems to be a paring knife. The crisp light and shadows give it a strangely intimate, almost domestic, feel. What stands out to you in this seemingly simple composition? Curator: Well, considering the period, this still life is rather interesting from a cultural perspective. During the 1930s, with the rise of photography and Modernism, everyday objects took on new meaning. The choice of apples, in particular, evokes the genre of still life painting, traditionally seen as symbols of abundance and perhaps, more subtly, temptation or knowledge. The addition of the knife shifts that reading slightly - perhaps it is intended as a domestic commentary? Editor: I see your point. The knife does add a slight edge, literally and figuratively. Do you think there is some class or economic commentary by combining symbols of comfort like food and hints of more practical necessities? Curator: Possibly. There’s a definite modernist influence in the clean lines and composition which avoids overly sentimental depiction, instead offering a stark realism. But considering the rise of photography at the time and its growing acceptance as fine art, the fact that the image is made via a photographic medium in this period is more interesting to me: it could have been painting but this method implies a certain intent. Did she intend a more accurate and democratic approach? The lack of detail of documentation limits any full consideration however. Editor: That's a fascinating thought! The choice of photography definitely adds a layer of socio-political commentary. It makes me wonder what the artist intended for her audience. Thanks, that makes me consider the piece more deeply! Curator: It makes me consider what historical traces of lived reality such an image conveys, beyond simple symbols and intention. This was an interesting discussion!