James J. Mutrie, Manager, New York, from the Old Judge series (N172) for Old Judge Cigarettes 1888

This small card, produced by Goodwin & Company in the late 19th century, features James J. Mutrie and was originally included in packages of Old Judge Cigarettes. The photographic print, likely an albumen or gelatin silver print, was a relatively new medium at the time. Its creation involved a complex chemical process, a departure from traditional artistic materials. The tonal range, the texture of the paper, and even the slight fading over time all contribute to its aesthetic. The card's purpose, however, was not purely artistic. It was a promotional item, a collectible meant to encourage brand loyalty and drive sales. This speaks to the growing consumer culture of the era, where even leisure activities like baseball became intertwined with commerce and consumption. The mass production of these cards highlights the shift towards industrial methods and the changing relationship between labor, leisure, and capitalism. Looking closely at the material and its context gives us a richer understanding of its cultural significance.